Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Are you being frank or rude?

Sometimes I feel that we don't know the difference between being frank and being rude, and between being polite and being hypocrite. It is a fine line, but while I view frankness and politeness positively, I view rudeness and hypocrisy negatively.

You show up at office with the shirt you bought over the weekend. You obviously believe it is a nice shirt, otherwise you wouldn't buy it. For the purpose of this sample let's assume that your next desk colleague, Dan, doesn't like your shirt.

Option #1: Dan voluntarily says he doesn't like your shirt. Dan is being rude.
Option #2: You ask Dan if he likes your shirt, Dan says "no". Dan is being frank.
Option #3: You ask Dan if he likes your shirt, Dan says "yes". Dan is being hypocrite.
Option #4: You ask Dan if he likes your shirt, Dan says that it is not his style, but he sees why others could like it. Dan is being polite.

Here is a rule that may help: if you don't have anything good to say, better to shut up, unless you were asked for your opinion.

Tel Aviv, Israel

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Plonit,

I like this post. But I disagree with some of your conclusions

I liked your view on thin lines separating frankness and rudeness, politeness and hypocrisy. However, telling the truth in a non-offensive way is never rude (#1).

If someone is telling the truth in a non offensive way, you will determine if he's rude or frank just according to whether he was asked or not. . .

Think about it. . .


Oded

linda1 said...

i prefer that you will grab me to the tiolet and tell "you are lo bakivun today" with what you put on your self this morning... rather then start and saying i can understand, bla bla bla, and sign here and here and here ;)

pumpkin

Plonit said...

Pumpkin, I had a good laugh reading your "sign here and here..." ;-D